My husband cheated on me for a full six months and I had no idea.
He always worked insane hours but since he aimed to be a partner at a prestigious Manhattan law firm I accepted it as all part of the job description. The letter from his assistant, which arrived one afternoon in July, caught me completely off guard.
The envelope was of plain white card stock; “Elizabeth Mitchell” scrawled across the front in thick, blue marker. The handwriting was distinctly feminine and I frowned as I tore open the flap and pulled out the single sheet of paper. A note, in that same female hand, was inside.
Mrs. Mitchell,
Your husband and I have been sleeping together since February. I’ve broken it off, and I’m so sorry. You were always so nice to me.
Ashley
I vaguely remembered her from the last Christmas party. She had been very petite, very blonde (they were always blonde), and very perky—my very opposite.
Jack was still at work and so I did the only thing I could think of: I placed the letter in the middle of the dining room table, grabbed my purse, and left the house. I spent the rest of the day in a library perusing the “New in Fiction” section, waiting for him to get home and discover the letter. I was halfway through a Grisham novel when the cell phone in my purse rang. It was him, calling from home. I wanted to answer but stopped. Would he deny it? Admit it? Would either matter?
The call went to voicemail. I watched the phone until it beeped, indicating the new message. I picked it up and dialed into my voicemail—my husband’s voice came on the line; he sounded panicked.
“Lizzie, baby, come home. Give me a chance to explain, okay?”
How do you explain cheating on your wife? I wondered. I deleted the message and as I placed the phone back into my purse it rang again. I had to answer eventually.
“Yeah?”
“Lizzie! Listen, that bitch is lying!”
There it was. No explanation. No apology. Flat denial. I flinched at his anger and held the phone away from my ear to protect my eardrum.
“I fired her today and she’s trying to get back at me!”
I didn’t know what to say. Except, “I don’t believe you.”
“Shit, Lizzie, I swear I never touched her! Drew can back me up on this. Ask him!”
Drew was his college buddy and fellow lawyer at the firm. Of course he would back him up whether Jack had actually cheated on me or not. His sheer desperation came through the phone in waves—he was screwed and he knew it.
“Honey, please come home. I love you.” His voice had grown quieter; the indignant tone replaced by one more obsequious. “Please say something.”
“I’m not coming home, Jack.”
“Sweetie, you’re confused and hurt. I understand. But we can’t do this over the phone, Lizzie.”
“Do what?”
“I’m not going to lose you in a damn phone call,” he spat. “Now come home so we can talk!”
Tears ran down my cheeks, unnoticed. “No, Jack, you won’t lose me in a phone call. You lost me when you started screwing your assistant.” I closed the phone, ignoring the concerned looks of the other library patrons, and stood up. On my way out the door I dropped the cell phone, which had begun to ring again, into the trashcan.
That was a little under a year ago.
I left New York to travel throughout the Midwest, leasing dingy apartments month to month. Moving had been a lot easier than I would have thought. I had given up my old life for Jack, so after the marriage dissolved there wasn’t much else for which to stay around. A few weeks ago I read an article in a travel magazine featuring Portland, Oregon and decided to go.
I now lived in a small bungalow in Sherwood, a suburb outside Portland (bought and paid for with part of Jack’s generous divorce settlement). My new home was sparsely furnished; the only mementos from my old life were my books and a silver-framed photograph of my parents, both of which had long since passed. The picture had been taken only a few weeks before they were killed in a car accident. I’ve memorized my parents smiling faces and the way my father’s hand rested comfortably on my mother’s shoulder—like it wouldn’t ever belong anywhere else. I was the spitting image of her, from her piercing green eyes to her soft, black hair.
I was happy in Portland, or at least as happy as I thought I’d ever be. I’d picked up the pieces left of myself from my failed marriage and scotch-taped them back together. And I had gotten a goldfish.
₪₪₪₪₪
Dan wiped a few drops of sweat from his brow as he packed up the last of his tools into the back of the SUV.
“Dan!”
He squinted in the sunlight to see a blonde woman coming toward him through the graveled driveway, teetering precariously in her pink high heels. She smiled as she tilted her face up at him—not in the way most people did, as his six-and-a-half feet tended to tower over them, but in an attempt to be seductive. Inwardly, Dan cringed.
“Can I buy you a drink?” she asked. “I appreciate all the hard work you did today.”
“It wasn’t a problem,” he replied, avoiding the question. “That’s my job.”
He owned a small carpentry business, something passed on from his father, and the recently divorced woman had “needed” a tree house for her son.
“Are you sure?” she asked, slightly crestfallen.
Dan rubbed his cheek a few times and made a mental note that he needed to shave. “Yeah, I have a couple more projects I need to work on today.” He headed around the SUV to the driver’s side door. “But thanks for the offer.”
She nodded, letting him pass without pressing the issue further. She watched the dark blue SUV until it turned around the corner and drove out of sight.
Inside, Dan shook his head. It had only been a matter of time before he’d have to turn her down. She’d been making her intentions clear for the past few weeks. At least her son had gotten a tree house out of it.
It wasn’t that Dan wasn’t interested in women—he definitely was. The right one just hadn’t come along. His girlfriend in college had been everything he’d thought a woman should be: beautiful, intelligent, and loving. She had gone to grad school and decided that Dan, who had dropped out before his senior year to take over the family business, wasn’t her future. Matthew, a fellow grad student, apparently was. Dan, who had been preparing to propose, found out about the relationship from her roommate.
He pulled into his driveway and noticed his neighbor, a woman who had recently moved in two houses down from him, unloading groceries from her car. He watched her for a moment, amused, as she tried to carry as many bags as humanly possible. He switched off the ignition and got out of the vehicle.
“Hey,” he said, raising a hand in greeting.
She looked over her shoulder quickly, nearly dropping a bag in the process. “Hello.”
Dan took a couple steps toward her. “Need some help?”
“I got it, thanks.” She didn’t look at him again. She moved to the house, arms full. One of the smaller bags fell unnoticed from her arms as she circled around the house to the back door.
Dan trotted through the yard separating their houses and picked up the bag, waiting until she reemerged. Moments later she came back around the corner and stopped, surprised to see him standing in her driveway.
He smiled sheepishly at her. “You dropped this.”
She took the bag from him slowly, as though she thought he might bludgeon her with it as soon as hand it over. She studied him for a quick moment—his short sandy-colored hair and clear, blue eyes. “Thank you.”
He held out his now-free hand in greeting. “I’m Dan. I haven’t had a chance to introduce myself since you moved in. I live two houses over.” He indicated with his head toward his home.
She paused, then took his hand and shook it. “Elizabeth.”
He looked into the trunk of her car and noticed a few more grocery bags. “I’ll get the rest of these for you.”
“You don’t have to,” she started to protest, but the bags were already in his hands and he slammed the trunk shut. “Okay.” She circled around the house and held the back door open for him as he stepped inside.
He placed the bags inside and took a sweeping glance around her kitchen/living room. “Empty” put it mildly. A brown leather couch occupied the far living room wall, and a bookshelf stood in one of the four corners. There was a small lamp to one side of the couch.
The kitchen was in much the same condition. Dishes took up one of the cupboards, leaving the rest to collect dust. He peeked in as she opened her refrigerator to start putting away some of the cold items. It contained a half-full jar of pickles and a ketchup bottle. A lonely looking goldfish swam lazily in a glass bowl on the otherwise bare counter across from the refrigerator.
“That’s Mr. Fish,” she said, looking over her shoulder to see what he was looking at.
“Mr. Fish?”
“I’m not good at naming things. My husband used to joke that our kids would all have numbers instead of names.” Her smile faded and she shook her head. “Can I get you something to drink?”
“Sure.”
She looked around the kitchen, embarrassed. “The only thing cold is water.”
He smiled, trying to warm her to him. “Water is great.”
She filled a glass with ice and water from the faucet. After handing it to him, she returned to the groceries.
“Is a lot of your stuff still in storage?” he asked, after taking a sip.
“What?”
“Your home is pretty empty,” he remarked. “I just figured you weren’t completely settled in yet.”
“This is everything.”
He took another sip of water and watched her put food items into the fridge. He watched her lean frame as it bent down to retrieve items of food and stretched to place them on upper shelves. “He left you.”
She flinched and slowly turned to face him. He fought an urge to hug her and wondered from where it had come.
“I left him.”
“He cheated on you.”
“Yeah.” She studied him for another moment. “Is it obvious?”
He shrugged. “Like recognizes like.”
She returned to the groceries, moving from the refrigerator to one of the bare cupboards. “Ah. So your wife was a cheater.”
“Girlfriend. We weren’t married yet.”
“Thank goodness for small favors,” she replied wryly.
He laughed. “It’ll get better.”
She stopped again, and looked at him curiously. “Who are you?”
He shrugged again. “I’m Dan. I live two houses down. Speaking of which…” He set the glass down onto the counter. “Thanks for the water, Elizabeth. It was good to finally meet you.” He held out his hand again, and she shook it more quickly this time.
“Likewise,” she replied politely.
₪₪₪₪₪
“She’s hot.”
Dan shot a look across his kitchen table to his brother, Kevin, who was sitting sprawled out on the other side. They usually had dinner together on Friday nights—it had become a tradition when their father had passed away Dan’s senior year of college.
“What? Just because I’m married I can’t notice women?”
“I don’t know. Let’s ask Mary what she thinks.”
“Yeah, let’s not.” Kevin muttered sullenly. “What’s her name?”
“Elizabeth,” Dan replied. “I didn’t get her last name.”
“Divorced?”
Dan nodded. “He cheated on her.”
“Damn.” Kevin stabbed his fork into his spaghetti thoughtfully. “So when are you going out with her?”
“I’m not.”
“Why the hell not?”
“I’m not having this conversation with you again.”
“That was six years ago, bro. When are you going to get over her?”
“It’s really not about that this time.”
“Whatever. Then go out with Elizabeth.”
“No, she doesn’t want that.” Dan pushed his half-finished plate away from him.
“Says who? You’re not all that ugly. For a butthead,” he amended.
Dan stood up and carried his plate to the sink. From his window he could see Elizabeth’s backyard. The summer grass was starting to get out of control. He wagered she didn’t even own a lawnmower. “There’s just something about her.”
“Ah yes, that elusive ‘thing’.”
“I just want to know her.”
Kevin brought his own plate over and placed it on the counter. “And you’re off to such a great start.”
Dan smacked his brother in the arm.
“So what’s your big idea?”
Dan looked back out the window. “I’m still working on it.”
₪₪₪₪₪
I rolled over in bed and tried to ignore the incessant buzzing sound from outside. Why do people feel the need to cut their grass so early? I thought as I pressed my head deeper into my pillow. Granted it was eleven o’clock, but it was a Saturday—a day meant for sleeping in.
Twenty minutes later I gave up and went into the kitchen to start some coffee. I had left the kitchen windows open during the night and the drone from the lawnmower was even louder. The coffee started to percolate, and as I yawned I looked out the window. Shocked, I opened the door and started walking quickly toward Dan—the cause of the noise. He was pushing a small mower through my yard. He smiled and stopped the machine as I approached.
“Good morning,” he said. Though it was still relatively cool, beads of sweat had begun to break out over his forehead from working in the bright sunlight.
“What are you doing?” I blurted. “You’re mowing my yard.”
He took a step over to me and whispered. “You took my answer.”
“But why?”
“’Cause it needed it.”
“Oh.” I looked up at him, feeling confused. “Do you, uh, need anything?”
“Another glass of water would be nice.”
“Okay.”
I rushed back into my kitchen, which now had that lovely coffee smell to it. As I filled a glass with ice water I realized, for the first time, what I must look like. I was still wearing my pajamas—blue Capri yoga pants and a gray tank top. And my hair was a mess.
“Stop it. He doesn’t care,” I muttered to myself. I carried the glass of water back outside and handed it to Dan, who had been waiting patiently next to the mower. He drained it quickly and handed it back.
“Thanks.”
“Um, I’m going to go back inside now,” I said, indicating my house with a thumb over my shoulder.
He smiled, his eyes teasing. “Okay. I’m going to stay out here now.”
“Yeah.”
Once inside, I went upstairs to take a quick shower and get dressed—the coffee forgotten. By the time I was out of the bathroom, Dan had finished with the yard and was nowhere to be seen. And I had never thanked him.
I left the house quickly and strode to his front door, though once I reached his porch I felt some of my resolve melting away. I was coming over to just say thanks? I stopped on the porch and vacillated between taking those three extra steps to his door and fleeing back to my house when the front door opened suddenly and Dan stepped out, looking as surprised to see me as I was him.
“Wantedtosaythankyou,” I blurted out in classic Elizabeth style. “I was surprised to find you in my backyard like that and forgot to say it before.”
He nodded and quickly ran one hand back and forth through his own freshly washed hair, sending droplets of water flying onto the porch. “I was happy to do it.”
I forced a tentative smile of my own as the realization dawned that I had nothing else to say to him. “Okay. Well. Bye.” I turned to leave but felt a hand on my arm stopping me.
“You want to get some lunch?”
₪₪₪₪₪
Dan glanced across the front seat of his SUV at Elizabeth. She sat quietly, watching the rain fall outside the window. The sunny morning had quickly turned into a rainstorm as they had sat in the restaurant. Her damp hair had curled—clinging to her head in thick strands and her cheeks were flushed, both from embarrassment at the current silence and the run from the restaurant to the car. Dan couldn’t remember seeing anyone more beautiful.
“It’s getting pretty bad,” she observed.
“This is nothing. Wait until the fall.”
As he spoke, the floodgates opened and torrents of rainwater descended onto the vehicle. Dan’s visibility was severed to only ten or fifteen feet and he eased off of the accelerator, letting the car slow naturally, instead of hitting the brakes.
“Ah, perfect timing.”
“Maybe we should pull over and wait it out,” Elizabeth suggested.
“I think you might be on to something.” Dan continued letting the SUV coast and pulled off onto the shoulder. There were no other cars around on this back road, but he turned on his emergency lights to make sure they weren’t hit from behind by an unobservant driver.
They looked at each other for a few moments, and Elizabeth shifted uncomfortably in her seat.
“Thanks again for lunch, but I—”
“You’re welcome.” Rain sluiced over the windshield in a steady curtain of water, and Dan cleared his throat as he looked out at the water-blurred landscape. “So what made you decide to pick Sherwood?”
“It felt right. I don’t have any family left and I’d never lived on the West Coast. And,” she smiled, “it’s about as far away from my ex as I could get. You know, without moving to Alaska or something.”
“I wish I had done that. Would’ve saved some heartache at any rate.”
“She really did a number on you,” Elizabeth said quietly. “Here you are—this incredibly nice, good-looking guy who must have women knocking down his door, but you’ve been single since her.”
“There aren’t any women knocking down my door,” Dan countered. “And I’m not that nice.”
She rolled her eyes. “Oh right. There’re tons of people who just randomly mow their neighbors’ lawns. You’re perfectly normal.”
He laughed—a happy, booming sound—and Elizabeth couldn’t help but join in. “At the risk of falling off this pedestal of niceness, I don’t randomly mow yards.”
“No?”
“I thought it would be a way to get to know you. Make you think I’m this incredibly nice, good-looking guy.”
“So you’re scheming your niceness.”
“Yep.”
“Well, at least you plan ahead.”
He smiled. “So what if I made plans for us to go out tomorrow? Food could be involved again. Or just a movie. I’ll try not to get us stuck in another thunderstorm.”
The smile faltered on Elizabeth’s face, and she quickly looked away from him. “Oh…I don’t think…”
“I won’t bite.” He raised his right hand. “Scout’s honor.”
“Dan, you are really nice, but—”
“I never understood that one,” he replied quickly, not wanting to give her a chance to refuse him. “Women always say that when they’re trying to say no. But the fact that the guy is nice should make them want to say yes, don’t you think?”
She turned red but remained silent.
“But you can’t blame a guy for trying,” he continued with a shrug. “I was just thinking, ‘Dan, you know this beautiful, intelligent woman who just moved into town, which means there isn’t any competition yet. If you don’t at least take the opportunity and ask her to do something, you’ll have confirmed your loserness for all time.’”
Elizabeth laughed, his demeanor visibly easing her tension. “Surely not for all time.”
“Well, for a while anyway.”
“I just don’t think I should.”
“Do you not like movies?” he asked innocently.
“You know it’s not that, I—”
“How about this: you go to a movie tomorrow afternoon. I’ll come in and sit next to you. I might share my popcorn, but I might not. We’ll watch the movie and afterward go our separate ways—if you want. You wouldn’t even have to talk to me unless I shared some popcorn. Then I’d expect a thank you.” He remained straight-faced, though he had that teasing look in his eyes.
She opened her mouth to refuse him again but stopped. Dan watched her, waiting patiently and hoping she’d change her mind.
“How would you know which movie I went to?”
He let out the breath he’d been holding. “I’d probably have to buy tickets to all of them and look in each theater one-by-one. Would you agree to wear an over-sized, goofy hat to help me pick you out in the crowd?”
She shook her head. “I hate over-sized, goofy hats.”
“That would make things harder for me.”
She looked out the window, thinking over his offer. Dan only slightly noticed that the downpour had ended as quickly as it had begun. Droplets of water rolled down the windshield as the sun launched an attempt to scatter the dark rain clouds.
“Dan,” she began. She swallowed. “I can’t. I’m sorry.”
He started the car and resumed driving home on the still-deserted road. “Here you are–this nice, attractive woman who does have guys knocking down her door, but you’ve been single since him.”
Elizabeth blinked and looked down at her hands, her face reddening once again.
₪₪₪₪₪
My sleep was again interrupted early Sunday morning, not from the sound of a lawnmower, but by pangs of remorse. I’d been mentally kicking myself since stepping out of Dan’s car. I remained in bed and looked up at the ceiling. I was terrified at the thought of letting a man into my life again—someone else to sleep with an Ashley. I knew I wasn’t strong enough to go through it all again.
Knowing sleep would not be returning, I threw off the sheet and dragged myself from bed. Mr. Fish greeted me enthusiastically (which isn’t saying much, fish-wise) when I entered the kitchen and peppered his bowl with fish flakes. He kept an eye on me as he munched his food.
“What are you looking at?” I muttered.
He flapped his gills knowingly in response.
“You just swim around in your little bowl all day. What do you know about it?”
He circled the bowl once as if in agreement. He stilled again and resumed looking at me, opening and closing his gills in his fishy wisdom.
“Okay, so maybe Dan wouldn’t be another Ashley-sleeper,” I conceded.
Mr. Fish flicked a fin.
I crossed the living room to the bathroom. Movement from my front yard stopped me and I veered away from the bathroom to the living room window, amused. Dan was bent over in my drive way, scrubbing the side of my car. A bucket of soapy water stood next to him and it looked like there was just as much of the water on him as the car.
I smiled.